Honda Vs. Toyota: Reliability Review

Honda Vs. Toyota: Reliability, Maintenance Costs, and Benefits of Owning

If you’re looking for a reliable and affordable used car in Indianapolis, choosing between Honda and Toyota, this comparative review from the Indy Auto Man car Indiana dealerships staff will help you make the right choice. According to statistics, now in the most competitive world market – the United States – every ninth car out of 15 that came off the assembly line belongs to the Japanese concerns Toyota and Honda. Millions of drivers are choosing these brands for their reliability, quality, and comfort.

The history of the competition between the Japanese automobile giants Honda and Toyota goes back over 80 years. These two brands are cult ones that have managed to conquer the world. Below, we’ll compare the features of Toyota and Honda vehicles.

Reliability of Honda and Toyota

Honda is known for its reliability, frequently earning accolades from respected organizations for its dependability and quality; for example, RepairPal gave it a 4.0 out of 5.0 reliability rating, placing it first among 32 brands.

Toyota is widely recognized for the reliability of its vehicles, as well. According to research, Toyota consistently stands out as one of the most reliable car brands, including in the 2024 J.D. Power study, with a score of 147 problems per 100 vehicles (PP100).

The principles of Japanese manufacturers are well-known: reliable durable components, modest interior, an average price for the end-user, and a selection of models and trims for different buyer categories.

• Honda is famous for its enduring engines and the minimum number of visits to the service station;
• Toyota gained recognition for life-long running and the best liquidity on the secondary market.

Engine Reliability

Fortunately for those choosing between Honda and Toyota, both brands have a reputation for reliability and have minor differences here. But in face-to-face combat, Toyota tends to gain more points; Honda, with their turbocharged power units, focused on performance, receives complaints from drivers who find them less reliable and more prone to repairs than engines of the past.

Safety

When it comes to safety, Toyota also trumps reliability. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety gave the Toyota Corolla a Top Safety Pick + Award, while Honda failed due to headlamp issues. The Corolla also has a few advanced features that Honda lacks, such as lane tracking assistance and road sign detection. In all respects, both Toyota and Honda tend to score above average in reliability, with Toyota slightly ahead of Honda.

Which is Cheaper, Toyota or Honda?

Honda has not so many models as Toyota, so the one-by-one price comparison is not always fair. To help you understand the pricing, we have listed the Toyota and Honda models of the same classes with their base price*. The range of Toyota vehicles starts from $17,750 to over $85,000, while the Honda lineup ranges from $16,000 to $37,000.

Comparable models of these brands usually have similar options and features.

Honda has no direct competitors for these Toyota models:

• Toyota Prius C $21,500
• Toyota Tundra $34,125
• Toyota Avalon $36,275
• Toyota Sequoia $50,000
• Toyota Land Cruiser $85,665

* Price disclaimer: all specified prices are recommended retail prices from the websites of manufacturing companies, valid at the time of publication.

What Brand Has Lower Maintenance Costs, Toyota or Honda?

Both brands are excellent value-wise. Neither Toyota nor Honda models are prone to capital repair problems. The maintenance costs associated with keeping them on the road for fifteen and more years are among the lowest in the industry, but Toyota has a slight edge over Honda. In its first ten years of operation, the average Honda costs its owner $7,500 in maintenance, lower than any other brand except Toyota at $6,000. This is especially true for buyers of certified pre-owned models.

Every new Toyota and Honda comes standard with a full but limited warranty. Each Toyota comes with a 36,000-mile or 36-month warranty, whichever comes first. The transmission cover, which protects the owner from the costly engine and transmission repairs, lasts for 60 months or 60,000 miles. New Honda also carries a 3-year/36,000-mile limited warranty. But the Honda powertrain warranty is shorter than that of Toyota and only covers the powertrain for 5 years or 60,000 miles.

Vehicle depreciation trends in 2025

Toyota and Honda continue to be top picks when it comes to resale value in 2025, with Toyota usually holding a slight lead. Models like the Toyota Corolla and Camry keep about 62–64% of their original value after five years, and trucks like the Tacoma do even better—often holding onto over 64%. Honda’s popular Civic and Accord aren’t far behind, keeping around 60–61% of their value over the same period.

On the maintenance side, Hondas tend to be a bit friendlier on your wallet, costing around $428 a year compared to Toyota’s $441. Both are well below the industry average of roughly $650, which makes either brand a smart choice for anyone wanting to keep upkeep costs reasonable.

If you’re shopping used in Indiana, the Toyota Corolla is a solid bet if resale value is your main goal—thanks to its great reliability and steady demand. The Honda Civic is also a favorite, especially for folks who want dependable, affordable transportation that’s easy and inexpensive to maintain. For those interested in SUVs, the Toyota 4Runner and Honda CR-V both hold their value well, with Toyota usually having the edge.

There are some things changing the game in 2025. Higher interest rates and economic ups and downs are cooling off demand a bit, and the fast pace of electric vehicle improvements means older EVs depreciate faster. Cars that don’t have the latest safety tech, hybrid options, or smartphone hookups tend to lose value faster these days because buyers really want those features. On top of that, supply chain glitches mean fewer newer used cars are available, which helps keep prices steady—especially for well-maintained Toyotas and Hondas.

Both brands are known for their reliability—Toyota vehicles tend to go the extra mile, with lower chances of major repairs compared to the majority of competitors.

Honda Vs. Toyota: What Brand to Buy?

Toyota wins with higher overall ratings and a more versatile lineup. However, Honda vehicles have their strengths too, especially in the SUV segment. Both Honda and Toyota are nearly equal in the plug-in and hybrid vehicle categories. But what benefits does the owner of each brand get?

Benefits of Owning a Honda

One category where Honda beats Toyota is speed, especially in sedans like the beloved Civic and Accord. The Civic Type R is not technically a sports car but is still the fastest model in the lineup. It is equipped with a 306-horsepower turbo-four-cylinder engine that accelerates from 0 to 60 mph in just over five seconds.

Honda also strives to excel in the SUV segment, and the CR-V is a great compact SUV thanks to its efficient drivetrain, wide interior dimensions, and upscale cabin.

All in all, whether you’re leaning toward Toyota or Honda, you’re picking a brand that’s dependable, holds its value, and won’t break the bank on upkeep. Toyota tends to win slightly in resale value, while Honda shines with lower maintenance and sportier, efficient models. At the end of the day, it’s about what fits your style and budget best—and either way, you’re making a great choice.

Where Honda Lags Behind

The Honda Ridgeline midsize truck scored higher than the Toyota Tacoma and has a decent towing capacity. However, you won’t get a full-size truck from Honda. And the competitor Toyota Tundra can tow 8,000 pounds more than the Ridgeline.

Another disadvantage of Honda vehicles is the lack of advanced infotainment features such as smartphone integration. This manufacturer doesn’t skimp on safety features, but you will have to pay extra for smartphone connectivity and a mid-sized touchscreen. Some consumers also complain that the controls are rather confusing.

Best Used Toyota Models in 2025

If you’re shopping for a used car in Indiana, it’s hard to go wrong with a Toyota. The Camry and Corolla—especially their hybrid versions—get high marks for reliability, comfort, and great gas mileage. SUVs like the RAV4 and Highlander are favorites for families, thanks to roomy interiors and lots of safety tech, while the 4Runner and Land Cruiser are ideal if your adventures take you off the beaten path. And if you’re all about saving on gas and reliability, the Prius is definitely worth a look—it’s hard to beat for fuel efficiency and long-term durability. Toyotas are known for their smooth ride, easy maintenance, and truly practical features, making them a go-to for all kinds of Hoosier drivers.

Best Used Honda Models in 2025

Honda also comes through strong in the Indiana used car market. The CR-V and its hybrid sibling are loved for their comfort, handling, and spacious cabins—perfect for daily commutes or road trips. The Civic and Accord both shine for their sporty feel and reliability, while the HR-V packs a surprising amount of space into a compact footprint. The Insight is a great pick for efficient, no-fuss driving, and the Odyssey remains a family favorite for its comfortable ride and flexible seating. Hondas are prized for being fun to drive, affordable to keep up, and long-lasting, which is exactly what many local buyers are after.

Used Toyota and Honda Models to Avoid

Not every Toyota or Honda is a sure thing in the Indiana market. With Toyota, it’s smart to avoid older Yaris and C-HR models, which have weaker reliability records, and watch out for certain Sienna minivans from problematic years.

For Honda, beware of late-model Fits that have had transmission headaches, the Clarity plug-in hybrid with known battery and parts issues, and some Pilot SUVs from earlier years that report more frequent problems.

The Toyota vehicles offer much value in terms of the features included. The Camry base trim offers smartphone integration, Bluetooth, a Wi-Fi hotspot, a USB port, and satellite radio; by comparison, the Honda Accord is only equipped with Bluetooth and one USB port.

The Toyotas also consistently last longer than any Honda. According to statistics based on consumer reports, Toyota is the second most reliable automaker after Mazda, and Corolla is the most reliable model. Honda didn’t even make it to the top 10 for average reliability.

Despite Toyota gaining one of the highest brand loyalty, that doesn’t mean it has no weak points. Many models have been cited as having the lowest boot capacity, which may not be suitable for large families. For example, the Accord has about two cubic feet more trunk space than the Camry.

The Toyota car may also have a less powerful drivetrain. The stock Civic has 158bhp, while the rival Corolla has just 139bhp. A motor that needs to run with a higher load also produces more noise.

Which Car Is Right for You?

If you’re on a tight budget, a used Toyota is a clear winner. These cars have more standard features, which makes them more profitable. A used model can also potentially last much more years than a used Honda.

However, if you value performance, Honda is the better choice. You may also prefer one of the Honda SUVs if you need a spacious luggage compartment. Whatever your preference, you can’t go wrong with either Honda or Toyota.

Visit the Indy Auto Man used car dealership, take both brands for a test drive to compare your feelings, and get professional advice on the selected models. This way you will find the best option to meet all your expectations.

Stock # R2819

2022 Toyota C-HR

XLE

46,183 miles

Condition:
Pre-owned

Guarantee

Sale price

$22,500

$359 / mo. est.

Stock # R2886

2021 Toyota C-HR

LE

16,278 miles

Condition:
Pre-owned

Guarantee

Sale price

$23,500

$375 / mo. est.

Stock # R2834

2022 Toyota Tacoma

SR5

49,980 miles

Condition:
Pre-owned

Guarantee

Sale price

$34,197

$546 / mo. est.

Browse all inventory

Stock # R2787A

2018 Honda Accord

EX

96,787 miles

Condition:
Pre-owned

Guarantee

Sale price

$18,750

$301 / mo. est.

Stock # J2500

2020 Honda Accord

Sport

75,901 miles

Condition:
Pre-owned

Guarantee

Sale price

$21,975

$351 / mo. est.

Stock # P1113

2017 Honda CR-V

EX-L

120,239 miles

Condition:
Pre-owned

Guarantee

Sale price

$17,790

$303 / mo. est.

Stock # R2911

2017 Honda Accord

LX

64,325 miles

Condition:
Pre-owned

Guarantee

Sale price

$16,990

$290 / mo. est.

Stock # Z4305

2020 Honda Ridgeline

RTL-E

86,090 miles

Condition:
Pre-owned

Guarantee

Sale price

$25,790

$412 / mo. est.

Browse all inventory